---
title: "18 Card Show Vendor Mistakes to Avoid"
url: https://tenthpocket.com/guides/card-show-vendor-mistakes
description: "Avoid costly buying, pricing, payment and security mistakes at card shows. Real examples and practical fixes from Holdr's own table."
author: "Glen Jones"
published: 2026-11-09
updated: 2026-11-17
publisher: TenthPocket
---

Mistakes

# 18 card show vendor mistakes that cost you money, and how to avoid them

By Glen Jones, Holdr. Updated 17 November 2026

The short answer

Most vendors worry about discounting too much. In our experience that is not where the money goes. The expensive mistakes happen when you buy: the wrong card, the wrong language, a new set that drops before your next show, or a flat rate that quietly eats your margin. After that come security, payments and not knowing whether the show actually made money.

We have made most of these mistakes ourselves. Here is what each one costs and what we do now.

## Buying: where the big money goes

1

### 1. Buying new sets as soon as they release

New sets often drop in value fast. Buy at today's price and by your next show the margin can be gone, so you end up selling at what you paid or less.

What happened to us

A helper on our table bought a graded Japanese promo from a new release at about $300 market. It is now about $200. Not a disaster, but a clear lesson.

Fix Decide your rule for new sets before the show, either pay less or wait until prices settle, and make sure everyone buying on your table knows it.

2

### 2. Skipping the checks on every card

Condition, language, set and version. Miss one and you pay the wrong price.

What happened to us

We bought a Japanese Ivysaur from the 151 set and paid the English price. About $50 gone on one card, and we have made a handful like it.

Fix Check the same four things on every card, in the same order: the right card, the right set and version, the right language, and its condition. A lightly played card is not a near mint card.

3

### 3. One flat buy rate across a whole lot

Paying, say, 80 percent on everything feels fair and simple. But you throw cheap cards in for free and round down when you sell them, and the margin on the low end disappears.

Fix Use different rates for different price bands, with cheap cards bought at a lower percentage than expensive ones. Tell sellers your rates up front. Honest rates also mean fewer deals that fall over at the last minute.

4

### 4. Buying cards nobody wants

Some cards just do not have many collectors. Certain Pokemon, certain Magic and Lorcana cards, and some products move far slower than others. A card that sits in your binder for six months is cash you cannot use.

Fix Keep a short list of what you will not buy, or only buy cheaply, and stick to it.

5

### 5. Letting helpers buy with no rules

A friend or family member covering your table wants to get a deal done. Without rules they will buy what you would have passed on.

Fix Write your buying rules down, or set them in your app: the rates, the cards you do not buy, and the most a helper can spend without checking with you.

6

### 6. Long trades that block the whole table

A 20 card trade done by looking up each card can take 20 to 30 minutes. While you are heads down, other customers stand at your table with nobody talking to them, and some leave. You never find out how many sales that cost.

Fix Speed up the lookup. A notebook beats a phone calculator, and a system beats a notebook. If someone wants one of your cards in the trade, put that card in first so you can see how close the deal is. If a deal will not come together, say so early.

7

### 7. Rushed deals with no line by line record

The end of a show is when vendors trade with each other, and it is rushed.

What happened to us

We sold a whole lot at pack down to a vendor taking cards back to Australia. We worked it out on phones and in our heads, and a card was left off the deal.

Fix Write every card in and every card out on one list, with a price on each, before money changes hands. Then both sides can see who owes whom.

## Security: the first thing new vendors get wrong

8

### 8. A table that makes stock easy to take

We have seen and heard more theft stories than we can count. Sealed product at the front edge of a table walks off on the way past. Whole booster boxes have gone that way.

Fix Keep sealed product at the back or behind you. Use display cases with no gap at the sides, or keep them shut so people have to ask.

9

### 9. Binders with nobody watching

Binders are always a risk. Somebody needs eyes on them the whole time.

Fix When a customer pulls cards out, ask them to put the cards on your side of the binder, not at the front of the table where something can be slid on top and walk away. Keep a tally.

10

### 10. Getting distracted

Theft happens when the vendor is busy, often in the middle of a long buy.

Fix If you are buying, have someone else watching the table. A small camera pointed at the table is cheap, puts people off, and shows what happened if something goes missing. Know what you started the day with so you can tell what you finished with.

## Money and payments

11

### 11. No cash, or forgetting the float

Cash is still how most people pay at New Zealand shows. We have run out, and we have forgotten the cash altogether. It now goes on the packing list straight after the cards.

Fix Bring a float of small notes and coins. We bring about $400 to $500, mostly $5 and $10 notes, coins and some $20s. Leave $50s and $100s at home; nobody wants to break them.

12

### 12. Only taking one way to pay

Every way to pay you do not take is a sale that walks to the next table.

Fix Take cash and an EFTPOS or card reader, charged, with a power bank. If you use TenthPocket, [set up card payments](https://tenthpocket.com/help/take-cards) and check [the fees](https://tenthpocket.com/help/card-fees) before the show.

13

### 13. Handing cards over on a bank transfer

Transfers can be faked or reversed, and you may be waiting for one to arrive while the customer says it has gone through. We have seen people take the cards and never be seen again. We do not take transfers at shows.

Fix Cash or card at the table. If you ever do take a transfer, the cards stay with you until the money is in your account.

14

### 14. Thinking cash in the bag means profit

This one fooled us for years. We always walked out with cash and card takings, so it felt like a good show. Then that money went straight into buying more cards for the next show.

Fix After every show, look at stock as well as cash: what you sold, what those cards cost you, what you bought, what the day cost, and what is left in your binders. A show only made money if all of that adds up.

## Pricing

15

### 15. No prices on the cards

Pricing at whatever Collectr says means looking up every card while the customer waits. When we started we were one of the few tables with stickers on every card, and it made selling far faster.

Fix Sticker every card before the show. See how to [print your card labels](https://tenthpocket.com/help/labels). Visible prices sell more, and you do not need signal to read a sticker.

16

### 16. Pricing too early

Prices move.

What happened to us

We priced a graded Ho-Oh early in the week. It jumped about $500 overnight and sat on our table well under market. We honoured the sticker, as you should.

Fix Price as close to the show as you can, and check your most valuable cards on the morning of the show.

## Planning and people

17

### 17. Leaving it to the last minute

Pricing the night before, packing on the morning, arriving late to load in. The more chaotic the start, the harder the whole day.

Fix Be packed the night before. Plan how the table will be laid out. Bring a trolley for load in and pack down.

18

### 18. No break plan and no basics

You will need the bathroom, food and water. Phones die and venue wifi is often overloaded.

Fix Have a helper or a plan for breaks. Bring snacks that will not mark cards, and wet wipes for your hands. Bring a power bank, and make sure your prices and records work without signal.

## One more, and it matters most

Treat every customer like they will come back, because the good ones do. Remember names and what people collect, tell people your rules, and be straight with them. Some vendors get a bad name and people stop coming back to them. Your reputation is worth more than any single deal.

How TenthPocket fits

## Built at our table, for yours

We built TenthPocket after making most of these mistakes at our own table at Holdr. It photographs a stack and prices every card by condition, keeps what you paid on every card, lets you [use your buy rates and rules at the table](https://tenthpocket.com/at-the-show), works with no signal, and shows stock and cash together at the end of the show.

It helps your second show far more than your first, because the first time is when your cards go in.

[Get the free checklist pack](https://tenthpocket.com/guides/checklist-pack?from=GUIDE-MISTAKES) [Try it on one binder, free until 31 December](https://app.tenthpocket.com/sign-up?offer=founding&amp;code=GUIDE-MISTAKES)

## Keep reading

[Getting startedYour first card show as a vendor](https://tenthpocket.com/guides/first-card-show) [EarningsHow to make more money at a card show](https://tenthpocket.com/guides/more-money-at-a-card-show)
